‘Opinion: What would Jesus make of today’s conspiracy theories?’
2023 saw a surge in conspiracy theories, with dangerous falsehoods spreading like wildfire. From the rise of antisemitism fueled by ancient anti-Jewish conspiracies to prominent figures like Elon Musk and Donald Trump spreading lies, these theories have become ingrained in the lives of many, influencing their decisions and beliefs. In fact, a shocking 14% of Americans, equivalent to the number of mainline Protestants in the country, can be classified as QAnon believers, according to polls conducted in 2021.
As a theologian, Aaron Rosen believes it is crucial to examine the distinction between dangerous truth-seeking and the pursuit of religious truth. In this context, Jesus offers valuable insights. In his teachings, Jesus often preferred to communicate hidden truths through parables, a form of instruction that leaves room for interpretation. When questioned about why he opts for this cryptic method, Jesus explains that it is because most people cannot perceive or understand the truth. Their sensory perceptions are scrambled due to sin, impairing their ability to see. Only those with faith can truly comprehend the parables.
This may seem unfair or undemocratic, as if truth should be equally accessible to all. However, Jesus’s intention is to safeguard the truth and preserve its precious otherness. Unlike conspiracy theorists who claim superiority over mainstream media followers, Jesus encourages his disciples to seek truths beneath the surface. His parables invite readers to read between the lines while acknowledging that the lines themselves are not fake.
Jesus’s approach underscores radical humility, as he imparts truth out of love and a desire for deeper connection. This starkly contrasts with figures like Giuliani, Jones, and Trump, who denounce fake news while peddling conspiracy theories. Instead of patient study and interpretation, conspiracy theorists promise simple answers to complex problems, often relying on social media platforms. Jesus, on the other hand, encourages a more profound exploration of truth.
By considering Jesus’s teachings, we can gain valuable insights into how to combat the grip of conspiracy theories in our society. It compels us to approach truth-seeking with humility, recognizing the limits of our understanding while seeking deeper connections. Jesus’s parables serve as a reminder that the pursuit of truth requires effort, patience, and an open mind. Rather than dismissing what we see as lies, we should strive to uncover hidden truths, just as Jesus intended.
In a world saturated with conspiracy theories, it is crucial to critically assess the beliefs that guide our lives. By taking Jesus’s approach to truth-seeking, we can navigate this disorienting world with greater clarity and understanding.
