Pope Francis Criticizes Backward U.S. Catholic Church, Urges Progress in Doctrine
In a private meeting with Portuguese members of his Jesuit religious order, Pope Francis expressed his concerns about the backwardness of certain sectors within the Catholic church in the United States. He criticized those who have replaced faith with political ideology and called for progress in Catholic doctrine.
During the meeting in Lisbon on August 5, Pope Francis emphasized the importance of understanding that Catholic doctrine allows for change over time. He stressed that a correct evolution in the understanding of matters of faith and morals is crucial and denounced the tendency to cling to outdated ideologies. The Pope warned that such a reactionary attitude leads to a climate of closure and disconnect from the roots of the church, resulting in devastating effects on morality.
The Pope’s remarks highlight the divisions within the U.S. Catholic Church, particularly between progressives and conservatives. Conservatives have been critical of Pope Francis’ reforms, which aim to give women and lay Catholics more prominent roles within the Church and create a more welcoming and inclusive environment for marginalized groups, including LGBTQ individuals.
Many conservatives have also voiced their opposition to the Pope’s emphasis on social justice issues, such as the environment and poverty. They have labeled his ideas as heretical, particularly his proposal to allow divorced and civilly remarried Catholics to receive the sacraments.
Pope Francis acknowledged the criticisms directed at him from some U.S. conservatives, jokingly stating that it was an honor to be attacked by Americans. However, he urged his critics to recognize the need for an appropriate evolution in the understanding of faith and morals.
As an example, the Pope mentioned that there were pontiffs in the past who were tolerant of slavery, but the Church evolved its stance over time. He emphasized the importance of avoiding a monolithic vision of Church doctrine and instead allowing for progress and consolidation based on a correct understanding of contemporary issues.
This call for progress and a more inclusive approach to Catholic doctrine is likely to resonate with many progressive Catholics around the world. However, it may also further deepen the divide between conservatives and progressives within the U.S. Catholic Church.
Pope Francis’ comments serve as a reminder of the ongoing challenges faced by the Church as it strives to navigate between tradition and modernity. As debates continue within the Church, the response to the Pope’s message will shape the future direction of Catholicism in the United States and beyond.
