Legal Battles Mount as Tamil Nadu and Kerala Challenge Governors’ Delay in Passing Crucial Bills, India


Updated: 12:35 PM, Mon November 20, 2023

Legal Tussle Mounts as Tamil Nadu and Kerala Challenge Governors’ Delay in Passing Critical Bills

The state governments of Tamil Nadu and Kerala have taken legal action against their respective Governors over delays in passing crucial bills. The move comes as both states accuse their Governors of undermining the rights of the people and causing unwarranted delays. The Chief Justice of India, D Y Chandrachud, has emphasized the need for Governors to take prompt action without requiring parties to approach the Supreme Court.

In Tamil Nadu, the government is expected to inform the Supreme Court about its state legislative Assembly’s re-adoption of 10 important bills that were previously returned by Governor R N Ravi without any reasons provided. The Governor’s inaction has led to a prolonged period of deadlock and constitutional uncertainty. Senior advocates A M Singhvi, P Wilson, and advocate Sabarish Subramanian will represent Tamil Nadu before the three-judge bench on November 20.

Similarly, in Kerala, the state government is preparing to challenge Governor Mohmmad Arif Khan in the Supreme Court. The government alleges that the Governor has been delaying the passage of eight key bills related to public health, higher education, and the establishment of Lokayukta, among other important issues. Some of these bills have been pending for nearly two years, causing significant frustration and hindrance to the state’s progress. Senior advocate K K Venugopal and advocate C K Sasi will represent Kerala in court.

These legal battles highlight a growing trend among non-Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) ruled states, as several of them are taking action against their Governors. The states argue that the prolonged delays in dealing with bills amount to a subversion of the Constitution and result in grave injustice for the people.

The Supreme Court’s involvement in these cases signifies the importance of resolving the disputes and ensuring that Governors fulfill their responsibilities in a timely manner. The court has issued notices to the union of India and requested the response of the Home Ministry, with the Attorney General of India or the Solicitor General of India required to be present during the hearing.

As the legal battles unfold, it is crucial to strike a balance between the powers of state governments and the role of Governors. The Chief Justice’s call for self-reflection and prompt action is a reminder that constitutional harmony is essential for the smooth functioning of democracy.

The outcome of these legal challenges will have significant implications for the relationship between state governments and Governors in India. The states of Tamil Nadu and Kerala are determined to ensure that their Bills are considered and assented to without any further delays. The Supreme Court’s decision will provide clarity on the powers and responsibilities of Governors, setting a precedent for future conflicts between state governments and constitutional authorities.

In conclusion, Tamil Nadu and Kerala’s legal battles against their respective Governors highlight the need for prompt action and respect for the rights of the people. The Supreme Court’s intervention will play a crucial role in determining the outcome of these disputes and will shape the balance of power between state governments and Governors in India.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) Related to the Above News

What are the legal battles taking place between Tamil Nadu and Kerala?

Tamil Nadu and Kerala are challenging their respective Governors in the Supreme Court over alleged delays in passing crucial bills.

What is Tamil Nadu's case against Governor R N Ravi?

Tamil Nadu claims that Governor Ravi delayed passing 10 crucial bills without providing any explanation, leading to constitutional deadlock.

How is Kerala challenging Governor Mohmmad Arif Khan?

Kerala is accusing Governor Khan of delaying several key bills, some of which have been pending for nearly two years, violating the fundamental right to life and being manifestly arbitrary.

What are the important bills that have been delayed in both states?

The bills include those related to public health, higher education, Lokayukta, and various other significant issues.

What do Tamil Nadu and Kerala argue in court?

Both states argue that the Governors' actions violate constitutional principles and undermine people's rights, resulting in grave injustice.

What comment did Chief Justice D Y Chandrachud recently make about state Governors?

Chief Justice Chandrachud emphasized that state Governors should reflect on their actions and take prompt action without requiring parties to approach the Supreme Court.

What actions has the Supreme Court taken in response to these legal battles?

The Supreme Court has issued notices to the Union of India and requested a response from the Home Ministry. The Attorney General of India or the Solicitor General of India is required to be present in court.

What is the central argument of Tamil Nadu against Governor Ravi?

Tamil Nadu alleges that Governor Ravi acted like a political rival and created a constitutional deadlock by excessively delaying the consideration and assent of bills passed by the legislature.

What is the date of the Supreme Court hearing on these issues?

The Supreme Court is scheduled to address these issues on 20 November.

What could be the potential consequences of these cases?

The outcome of these cases could have significant implications for the relationship between state governments and Governors in India, as well as the limits of gubernatorial power.

Please note that the FAQs provided on this page are based on the news article published. While we strive to provide accurate and up-to-date information, it is always recommended to consult relevant authorities or professionals before making any decisions or taking action based on the FAQs or the news article.

Siddharth Mehta
Siddharth Mehta
Siddharth Mehta is a dedicated author at The Reportify who covers the intricate world of politics. With a deep interest in current affairs and political dynamics, Siddharth provides insightful analysis, updates, and perspectives in the Politics category. He can be reached at for any inquiries or further information.

Share post:



More like this

German Govt’s Bitcoin Sell-Off Boosts Market Confidence, Germany

German Govt's Bitcoin sell-off boosts market confidence, sparking optimism among investors amid stable prices. Learn from this event for future investments!

First Human Case of West Nile Virus Confirmed in Cook County, Illinois, US

First human case of West Nile Virus confirmed in Cook County, Illinois. Learn how to 'Fight the Bite' and protect yourself from mosquito-borne illnesses.

ASB Classic 2025 Returns with World-Class Tennis Stars in Auckland, New Zealand

Experience world-class tennis action as ASB Classic 2025 returns with top global stars in Auckland. Book your tickets for this premier event now!

Rare Rattlesnake Den Cam Reveals Surprising Behavior in Colorado, US

Rare Rattlesnake Den Cam in Colorado reveals surprising behavior of these misunderstood creatures. Learn about their social and caring nature.