Israel’s Claim of Hamas Using Al-Shifa Hospital as a Detention Center Called ‘Misleading’ by Palestinian Group


Updated: 1:57 PM, Mon November 20, 2023

Israel’s Claim of Hamas Using Al-Shifa Hospital as a Detention Center Called ‘Misleading’ by Palestinian Group

In a recent development, a Palestinian group has refuted Israel’s claims of Hamas using Al-Shifa Hospital in Gaza as a detention center for prisoners. The group, Hamas, stated that these claims by the Israeli occupation army are misleading and false, highlighting a desperate attempt to cover up their security and military failures.

Hamas further criticized the Israeli army for spreading lies and misinformation, particularly regarding their alleged detention of Zionist prisoners and the discovery of a female soldier’s body in Al-Shifa Hospital. The group firmly asserted that these accusations are baseless and merely fabricated to falsely implicate Hamas.

To support their argument, Israeli government spokesman Ofir Gendelman released videos on the X platform showcasing what he claimed to be hostages taken by Hamas to Al-Shifa Hospital after an attack on October 7. Gendelman pointed out that one of the prisoners, injured and lying on a hospital bed, was captured on video, while the other was seen being taken away while walking. The prisoners were identified as a Thai citizen and a Nepalese citizen.

Meanwhile, Israeli army spokesman Daniel Hagari asserted in a press conference that Hamas fighters had killed female soldier Noa Marciano within Al-Shifa Hospital. However, Hamas vehemently denied these allegations and emphasized that their military wing, Al-Qassam Brigades, had closely monitored and treated injured Zionist prisoners in hospitals before safely returning them to their places of detention. Consequently, Hamas regarded the Israeli military spokesman’s statements as an attempt to conceal the lies propagated by the Israeli army.

In a worrying development, it was reported that the Israeli army forcibly evacuated approximately 500 patients from Al-Shifa Hospital, including those severely injured due to relentless Israeli attacks, leaving them to fend for themselves in dire conditions.

Since the beginning of Israel’s bombing campaign on October 7, the devastating consequences have been immense. According to the latest figures, over 13,000 Palestinians, including more than 9,000 women and children, have lost their lives, with over 30,000 others sustaining injuries. Furthermore, numerous buildings, including hospitals, mosques, and churches, have been severely damaged or destroyed.

The situation has been compounded by an Israeli blockade that has disrupted essential supplies of fuel, electricity, and water to the besieged Gaza Strip, drastically reducing aid deliveries.

While the Israeli death toll stands at approximately 1,200, it is crucial to approach this issue from a balanced perspective, acknowledging different viewpoints and opinions.

The ongoing tensions between Israel and Palestine continue to exact a heavy toll on innocent lives and infrastructure. It is imperative that steps be taken towards finding a peaceful resolution and putting an end to this cycle of violence and destruction.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) Related to the Above News

What is the current conflict between Israel and Hamas about?

The current conflict between Israel and Hamas stems from longstanding tensions and disputes over territory, security, and the rights of Palestinians living in Gaza.

What is the specific claim made by Israel regarding Al-Shifa Hospital?

Israel has claimed that Hamas is using Al-Shifa Hospital as a detention center for prisoners, including hostages taken after an attack on October 7.

What is Hamas's response to Israel's claim?

Hamas has strongly denied Israel's claim, labeling it as misleading and false. They accuse Israel of attempting to cover up their own security and military failures.

What evidence does Israel present to support their claim?

Israel's government spokesman released videos showing injured prisoners in Al-Shifa Hospital, alleging that Hamas had taken them hostage. They also claimed that a female soldier was killed by Hamas fighters inside the hospital.

How does Hamas refute Israel's claim?

Hamas states that their military wing has only monitored and treated injured prisoners before returning them to their places of detention. They argue that Israel's accusations are an attempt to conceal their own lies.

Has there been any other incident involving Al-Shifa Hospital?

Yes, the government media office in the Gaza Strip accused the Israeli army of forcibly evacuating approximately 500 patients from Al-Shifa Hospital, leaving them stranded on the streets without adequate medical care.

What is the current toll of the conflict in terms of casualties and destruction?

As of the current date, over 13,000 Palestinians have been killed, including more than 9,000 women and children. More than 30,000 individuals have been injured, and numerous buildings, including hospitals, mosques, and churches, have been damaged or destroyed.

What impact has Israel's blockade had on Gaza?

Israel's blockade has exacerbated the dire humanitarian situation in Gaza, causing shortages of fuel, electricity, and water supplies. It has also limited aid deliveries, further straining the already challenging circumstances for the Palestinian population.

Is there a difference in the casualty figures between Israel and Palestine?

Yes, according to official figures, the Israeli death toll stands at around 1,200, which is significantly lower than the Palestinian death toll.

What is the importance of presenting a balanced view in this situation?

The conflicting narratives between Israel and Hamas underscore the deep divisions and ongoing conflict in the region. It is crucial to present a balanced view that considers different perspectives and strives for a peaceful resolution.

Please note that the FAQs provided on this page are based on the news article published. While we strive to provide accurate and up-to-date information, it is always recommended to consult relevant authorities or professionals before making any decisions or taking action based on the FAQs or the news article.

Siddharth Mehta
Siddharth Mehta
Siddharth Mehta is a dedicated author at The Reportify who covers the intricate world of politics. With a deep interest in current affairs and political dynamics, Siddharth provides insightful analysis, updates, and perspectives in the Politics category. He can be reached at for any inquiries or further information.

Share post:



More like this

Trump Trade Tensions Surge, Gold Opportunity Rises, Russia

Trump Trade tensions surge, gold opportunity rises - seize the chance of a lifetime with this stunning look at gold. Exciting times ahead!

German Govt’s Bitcoin Sell-Off Boosts Market Confidence, Germany

German Govt's Bitcoin sell-off boosts market confidence, sparking optimism among investors amid stable prices. Learn from this event for future investments!

First Human Case of West Nile Virus Confirmed in Cook County, Illinois, US

First human case of West Nile Virus confirmed in Cook County, Illinois. Learn how to 'Fight the Bite' and protect yourself from mosquito-borne illnesses.

ASB Classic 2025 Returns with World-Class Tennis Stars in Auckland, New Zealand

Experience world-class tennis action as ASB Classic 2025 returns with top global stars in Auckland. Book your tickets for this premier event now!