It’s no secret that guitarists have strong opinions when it comes to their craft. From favorite guitarists to album choices, there are always controversial hot takes that can either divide opinion or alienate playing peers entirely. youtube.There’s always room for some spirited debate when it comes to music, especially in the guitar world. Guitarists are a passionate bunch, and their hot takes can be both thought-provoking and divisive. So, buckle up and get ready to have your feathers ruffled with these six-string hot takes.
In a recent YouTube video, the Samurai Guitarist (AKA Steve Onotera) embarked on a mission to uncover some of the most controversial guitar opinions on the platform. Joined by 17 players, including himself, he delved into a round table discussion that was bound to spark some intense debates.
One of the most controversial opinions came from Phil McKnight, who dared to claim that It’s harder to play country than jazz. This statement is sure to incite the wrath of jazz musicians worldwide. McKnight argues that country players, especially those who excel in bending notes to achieve the perfect pitch, possess a superior level of ear training and technique compared to jazz guitarists. While it’s easy to understand the challenging nature of jazz chords, there’s no denying that nailing those country bends requires exceptional finger control and a finely tuned ear.
Rhett Shull, a session ace, had some choice words for pop country and bro country. He boldly called it bad for music in general. According to Shull, this subgenre of country produces disposable, meaningless music that lacks substance. He believes that it is detrimental to both musicianship and the overall music listening experience. Clearly, Shull has no love for bro country or its pop-infused offshoot.
Dovydas and Ryan Burke added their own controversial takes to the mix. Dovydas touched on the age-old debate of gear versus player, asserting that the belief in a single pedal or piece of gear magically transforming one’s music is a fallacy. He suggests that the focus should be on honing one’s skills and songwriting abilities rather than expecting a transformative effect from a single piece of equipment. On the other hand, Burke challenges guitarists who dismiss popular music, arguing that paying attention to mainstream music can actually benefit musicians. By examining what makes these popular songs appealing to millions, guitarists can broaden their own musical horizons and improve as musicians.
The video showcases even more provocative opinions from notable players like Sean Daniel, Tilly Shull, Corey Congilio, and Mike Cole. These takes range from labeling Nickelback as underrated, criticizing the Beach Boys, and even questioning the validity of The Doors’ acclaim.
While these hot takes may spark intense debates, it is essential to remember that music is subjective, and opinions differ greatly from person to person. The beauty of music lies in its diversity and the multitude of perspectives it offers. Controversial opinions like these can encourage healthy discussions and the exploration of different genres and playing styles. Regardless of whether you agree or disagree with these takes, they provide a fresh perspective and challenge us to think critically about our own musical preferences.
If you’re intrigued by these controversial guitar opinions, head over to Samurai Guitarist’s YouTube channel to watch the full video and join the conversation. Who knows? You might find yourself reevaluating your own guitar beliefs. But remember, at the end of the day, it’s all about the joy of playing and the infinite possibilities that music brings.
