Why is Liberal Ideology Suppressed in the Middle East? Understanding the Complexities of Governance and Power


Updated: 9:56 PM, Mon November 20, 2023

Why is Liberal Ideology Suppressed in the Middle East?

Amidst ongoing debates surrounding the Israeli-Palestinian conflict and the Gaza war, one intriguing question remains unanswered: why is liberal ideology a minority view or even totally suppressed in the Middle East? Western intellectuals and commentators often weigh in confidently on the matter, but how well do they truly understand the complexities and realities of the region? Have they lived or spent a significant portion of their lives in the Middle East?

It raises a fundamental question: can someone who has never tasted a green apple truly comprehend its flavor, no matter how many books they have read or people they have spoken to about it? Similarly, have these commentators ever taken the time to question why countries in the Middle East, including those bordering Israel, do not prioritize human rights, freedom of expression, freedom of the press, or LGBTQ+ rights? Why is liberal ideology a minority view, or even suppressed, in this entire region spanning from Afghanistan to the shores of the Mediterranean?

The answer is clear to anyone who has grown up or lived in the Middle East: the foundations of leadership in these countries rest on strength, honor, power, and often religious influences. These concepts simply do not align with the principles of leadership found in liberal democracies around the world. In essence, we are dealing with different people, ways of life, beliefs, and perspectives.

Historically, attempts to impose Western models of governance in the Middle East have been met with limited success. Examples such as the ill-fated Operation Freedom in Iraq in 2003, the short-lived democracy in Afghanistan following the invasion, and even the aftermath of Egypt’s Arab Spring in 2012, where the Muslim Brotherhood rose to power, highlight the challenges faced in implementing Western-style democracies. These instances ultimately resulted in unrest, alternative leadership, or the reassertion of traditional power structures.

Israel stands apart from its neighbors in the region. While it aspires to be a part of the Western world and uphold liberal democratic values, it finds itself surrounded by Hezbollah, Hamas, and the regime of President Assad in Syria. As a result, Israel must navigate a complex and challenging landscape, often in contradiction to the fundamental beliefs of the progressive left.

There have been periods when Israel lived up to the humanitarian standards observed by countries bordering Wales or Canada, such as during the mid-1990s after the Oslo Accords were signed. Yet, there are also times, like the present, where Israel is dragged into war. In those moments, speaking the language understood and respected by its neighbors becomes necessary for its survival.

To those who criticize Israel’s use of power in conflict situations and propose alternative ways to combat Hamas, Hezbollah, or the jihadists in Syria, who invade or plan to invade Israeli territory and perpetrate heinous acts, it is essential to invite them to live in the region for a few years. It is only by experiencing the realities on the ground that one can fully comprehend the challenges Israel faces and the complexities involved in defending its nation against those who use civilians as shields and commit atrocities.

In conclusion, the suppression of liberal ideology in the Middle East is a result of the distinct cultural, historical, religious, and political dynamics at play in the region. While Western commentators may hold firm beliefs and idealized visions of how governance should be, it is crucial to recognize that different regions have different contexts. It is only through a nuanced understanding, lived experience, and genuine dialogue that progress and change can be fostered in the Middle East.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) Related to the Above News

Why is liberal ideology suppressed in the Middle East?

Liberal ideology is suppressed in the Middle East due to a variety of factors, including differing cultural values, historical contexts, and power dynamics. The region operates under principles of leadership that prioritize strength, honor, power, and religion, which do not align with the foundations of liberal democracy. Additionally, attempts by Western countries to impose their governance models in the Middle East have often failed, leading to a reluctance to embrace liberal values.

Are there any countries in the Middle East that embrace liberal democracy?

No, there are currently no countries in the Middle East or North Africa region that fully embrace liberal democracy akin to those in Europe or the United States. Liberal ideology is either a minority view or entirely suppressed in this region.

How does Israel's position in the Middle East impact its embrace of liberal democracy?

Israel finds itself in a unique position, aspiring to be part of the Western world and embrace liberal democracy while being surrounded by neighbors that often challenge these principles. The presence of groups like Hezbollah, Hamas, and the regime of President Assad in Syria forces Israel to navigate a complex landscape, sometimes resulting in contradictions that challenge progressive left-wing principles.

Has there been any period in which Israel has embraced humanitarian standards?

Yes, there have been periods, such as in the mid-1990s after the Oslo Accords, when Israel lived up to humanitarian standards observed by countries in Western Europe or North America. However, during times of war and conflict, Israel's focus shifts towards survival, necessitating different approaches and actions to protect its citizens.

What should be considered when analyzing the suppression of liberal ideology in the Middle East?

When analyzing the suppression of liberal ideology in the Middle East, it is crucial to understand the complexities of governance, power dynamics, and cultural differences. Balancing different perspectives and recognizing the realities on the ground, such as ongoing threats and conflicts, will contribute to a more comprehensive understanding of the challenges faced by the region.

Please note that the FAQs provided on this page are based on the news article published. While we strive to provide accurate and up-to-date information, it is always recommended to consult relevant authorities or professionals before making any decisions or taking action based on the FAQs or the news article.

Siddharth Mehta
Siddharth Mehta
Siddharth Mehta is a dedicated author at The Reportify who covers the intricate world of politics. With a deep interest in current affairs and political dynamics, Siddharth provides insightful analysis, updates, and perspectives in the Politics category. He can be reached at siddharth@thereportify.com for any inquiries or further information.

Share post:



More like this

Huawei Cloud Summit Unveils 10 AI Innovations at MWC Barcelona, Spain

Discover the latest AI innovations unveiled at Huawei Cloud Summit at MWC Barcelona, shaping the future of cloud computing.

Ant Group Outbids Citadel for Credit Suisse’s China Venture, Switzerland

Ant Group outbids Citadel in high-stakes battle for Credit Suisse's China venture. China's fintech giant faces scrutiny as UBS weighs its decision.

Pedro Pascal and Kieran Culkin’s Hilarious Fake Feud at Award Shows in 2024

Pedro Pascal and Kieran Culkin engage in a hilarious fake feud at award shows, keeping fans entertained with their playful banter and lighthearted rivalry.

Researchers from Penn Develop Unique Framework to Quantify Common Sense, US

Researchers from Penn tackle a significant deficiency in the...